Apple Cider Bourbon Cocktail (Apple Cider Old Fashioned)
This Apple Cider Old Fashioned has bourbon, fresh apple cider, maple syrup and orange bitters, but no cocktail shaker or homemade syrup to fuss with. It is a five-minute fall cocktail you can make right in the glass.

“This was a big hit at Thanksgiving! Wonderful fall flavors, and the garnishes added a visual appeal and some tasty fruit flavors. A taste of autumn with every sip! Definitely keeping this one in my rotations and have enjoyed in the cooler evenings with friends around the fire pit!”
—Pauline
“This is a great fall cocktail. Well balanced and not too sweet. I made one with maple syrup and one without (the last one for my husband) and they’re both delicious. He just exclaimed ‘boy this is good!'”
—Jessica
A Michigan Apple-Season Twist On My Favorite Old Fashioned
Fall in Michigan means apple season, and an apple cider version of my favorite cocktail was a natural next step. I love a classic old fashioned, but sometimes it is a little stronger than I want. Adding apple cider makes this version a little easier to sip while keeping the bourbon, orange peel and bitters that make it recognizable as an old fashioned.
Instead of muddling a sugar cube, I use maple syrup, which pairs nicely with the apple cider and stirs right in. There is no shaker and no cider reduction to cook. Just build the cocktail in the glass, add ice, and you are ready to serve.
This Apple Cider Old Fashioned has become a reader favorite for Thanksgiving, and it’s easy to see why. It’s festive enough for a holiday gathering but requires just five minutes, a handful of ingredients and no cocktail shaker. Whether you’re making one for yourself while the turkey finishes roasting or mixing up a few for guests, it’s a simple way to make Thanksgiving feel a little more special.
Why You Will Love This Apple Cider Bourbon Cocktail
- A lighter-tasting take on an old fashioned. Three ounces of apple cider soften the bourbon’s intensity.
- No shaker, no special syrup. Maple syrup dissolves easily, and the whole drink is mixed in the serving glass.
- Easy for one or a few. Make individual drinks for a fall evening, or mix the base ahead for Thanksgiving guests.

Apple Cider Old Fashioned Ingredients
A full recipe card, including exact ingredient amounts, appears at the bottom of this post.
- orange peel – releases fragrant citrus oils when lightly muddled. It gives the drink that unmistakable old fashioned aroma.
- orange bitters – act like a seasoning for the cocktail, balancing the cider and maple syrup with a slightly bitter citrus note.
- maple syrup – takes the place of the traditional sugar cube. I like how its flavor works with cider, and you can adjust it to suit your taste.
- bourbon – provides the whiskey backbone. I like Bulleit for old fashioneds, but Woodford Reserve, Maker’s Mark, Buffalo Trace and Four Roses also work.
- apple cider – use fresh, nonalcoholic apple cider if you can get it, especially a good local Michigan cider in fall. It is the main flavor here, so choose one you enjoy drinking.
- ice – chills the cocktail once everything is mixed. Use enough to keep the drink cold while you sip.
- apple slices, cinnamon sticks and/or cocktail cherries – optional garnishes that make a simple glass feel ready for fall entertaining.
How To Make An Apple Cider Old Fashioned

- MUDDLE. Add the strip of orange peel, orange bitters and maple syrup to a rocks glass. Gently press the peel with a muddler to release its oils.

- STIR. Pour in the bourbon and apple cider, then stir until the maple syrup is combined with the drink.

- ADD ICE AND GARNISH. Fill the rest of the glass with ice (either smaller cubes or one large ice cube) and serve immediately. Add apple slices, a cinnamon stick or cocktail cherries if you like.
Home Chef Tips For An Apple Cider Old Fashioned
- Be gentle with the orange peel. You just want to release the oils, not grind the peel into oblivion. A few gentle presses are enough.
- Let the cider guide the sweetness. Taste your cider first. If it is especially sweet, cut back on the maple syrup or leave it out.
- Use rye whiskey when you want more spice. It will give this cider cocktail a different character than the rounder flavor of bourbon.

Apple Cider Old Fashioned Variations
- BRANDY – Swap in brandy for the bourbon if you enjoy the Midwest old fashioned tradition.
- WITHOUT BOURBON – Omit the bourbon for a cider-based mocktail. If you need it to be completely alcohol-free, use alcohol-free bitters as well; traditional cocktail bitters often contain alcohol.
Make Ahead, Storage And Freezing
- Make Ahead: For a party, combine the bitters, maple syrup, bourbon and cider a few hours before serving. Refrigerate until ready to serve, then add orange peel, ice and garnishes to individual glasses. If you need a larger-format drink, try my Bourbon Apple Cider Punch.
- Refrigerate: Keep any pre-mixed cocktail covered in the refrigerator until serving. It tastes best made and served the same day.
- Freeze: Freezing is not recommended for this cocktail. It is best served freshly mixed or chilled from the refrigerator.

More Foxes Love Lemons Favorites

Apple Cider Old Fashioned Cocktail
Save This Recipe!
Ingredients
- 1 strip orange peel about 1 inch wide
- 2 – 4 dashes orange bitters
- 1 teaspoon maple syrup
- 2 ounces bourbon
- 3 ounces apple cider
- Ice
- Sliced apples, cinnamon sticks and/or cocktail cherries, for garnish (optional)
Instructions
- Place orange peel, bitters and maple syrup in small glass and use muddler to gently release oils from orange peel.
- Add bourbon and cider; stir until well combined. Top glass with ice and serve immediately, garnished with apple slices, cinnamon sticks and/or cocktail cherries, if desired.

This was a big hit at Thanksgiving! Wonderful fall flavors, and the garnishes added a visual appeal and some tasty fruit flavors. A taste of autumn with every sip! Definitely keeping this one in my rotations and have enjoyed in the cooler evenings with friends around the fire pit!
I’m so glad to hear this was a hit for Thanksgiving, Pauline! Have a great Christmas as well.
Absolutely delightful cocktail! We made it with unfiltered apple cider and Basil Hayden bourbon, one with maple syrup (for me) and one without (for my husband who prefers things slightly less sweet). Also garnished with a cinnamon stick for aromatics. This will most definitely become a staple for our holiday celebrations! So yummy!!
I’m so glad to hear that, Jessica!
Something didn’t work. It was awful! I used Four Roses bourbon.
Hi Debra – Can you give me some more details about why it was awful? Was it too sweet? Too strong? Did you follow the ingredients and instructions exactly as written?
I am so with you on the Michigan apples and cider, there is no better! I grew up in Michigan and even worked at a cider mill during high school, sadly that particular mill no longer exists. I now live in north Georgia and the cider here just can’t compete. Thankfully my parents who still live in Michigan send me two gallons of frozen Yates Cider every fall which I hoard like it’s “My Precious.” One stays frozen to drink in the Spring to help stave off the cravings, one I thaw immediately and enjoy sparingly. I make cocktails and cook with it. I’ve had Georgia friends say the cider from here is the best (it’s NOT) so I did a blind taste test with their favorite and mine, all of them picked the Michigan cider from Yates as their favorite. I no longer have a local source for Michigan apples since Earth Fare left my area, but at least I can still get some of the best cider in the world delivered.
I make the drink above all the time minus the maple syrup and it’s fantastic. Happy Autumn! 🍎
What a small world! My last name is Yates! No relation to the cider mill family, although we do like to pretend. But it’s our preferred cider mill because YES the cider is the best! And the warm donuts, which I’m afraid won’t ship as well as the cider. But I’m glad you’re able to enjoy your precious cider hoard 🙂