Apple Rose Tart with Peanut Butter Custard

by Lori Yates October 11, 2021 6 comments

This Apple Rose Tart with Peanut Butter Custard is a showstopping, delicious dessert that YOU can make at home, even if you’re not a baker or pastry person. Promise!

Rectangular tart topped with apple "roses" on vintage baking pan with bowl of peanut butter and powdered sugar sifter.

If the first thing you think when you look at this apple tart is “there’s no way I can make that,” think again. Seriously, I’m SO not a baker or a “pastry person”.

I’m MUCH more comfortable with savory things like salmon pasta or lasagna recipe cottage cheese. There’s a reason 98% of the recipes on this blog are for savory foods or cocktails.

In fact, TRUE STORY: in culinary school, the pastry instructor forced me to BUY one of the cakes I made in class and take it home because it was so ugly.

Chef said my cake was so messed up that he couldn’t sell it at the school’s bake shop, so I would have to purchase it myself. Talk about embarrassing. I couldn’t wait to get out of that class and into a savory rotation.

So yeah, when I say I’m not a baker or pastry person, I mean it (although I can whip up a mean batch of Thanksgiving Rice Krispies treats). Since that experience, I’ve been on a mission to create beautiful, delicious things that are actually attainable for home cooks.

My frozen yogurt pie, cranberry curd pie and coconut creme brulee are some of my favorite examples, along with the apple rose dessert I’m sharing today.

So, stir up an apple cider mule, and let’s walk through this Apple Rose Tart with Peanut Butter Custard, element by element. We’ve got this.

Apple tart made with decorative roses made from apples, cut into pieces on vintage baking pan, with bowl of peanut butter and fresh apples nearby.

I used a refrigerated pie crust for this apple tart.

Look, homemade pie crust is great if that’s something you enjoy making, but I don’t. I almost always use refrigrated pie crust from the grocery store (usually Pillsbury brand, that comes in a red box with two rolls of pie crust). I use it for mini shepherd’s pies and vegetarian quiche and brownie pie, and everything in between.

I made this apple rose tart in a 14×5-inch rectangular tart pan, but with a refrigerated pie crust that was made for a 9-inch round pie. How did I do it?

I laid the pie crust across as much of the pan as I could, and then I used the trimmings from where the crust overlapped the pan to piece together the section of the pan that wasn’t covered.

So yes, I kind of Frankensteined the crust together for this apple tart. Because the crust gets covered with both custard and a million apple roses, the Frankencrust really isn’t an issue in the end. Nobody will EVER notice.

Alternatively, if you ARE a pastry person and you’re using homemade pie crust (this pie crust recipe from NYT Cooking has over 2,000 five star reviews, so that might be a good place to start), you can roll it out into a rectangle instead of a circle.

Be warned: the peanut butter custard is irresistible.

My #1 tip about the custard is to try to ignore it while it cools. Because this custard is AMAZING, and you’ll want to eat it all with a spoon. It’s dangerous. Try to resist. You need it for your apple rose tart!

Side note: why is peanut butter so good? Even in savory things like my Asian noodle salad recipe, I cannot resist it.

Beyond not eating all of it with a spoon before you assemble the tart, the main thing you’ll want to keep in mind for the custard is that you really do need to whisk it constantly while it cooks, so this isn’t the time to try to multitask and unload the dishwasher.

Just like pumpkin creme brulee and chocolate creme brulee, whisking it constantly keeps it smooth and prevents the eggs from turning into little bits of scrambled eggs.

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?

Enter your email below and we'll send it to your inbox.

Even with all the whisking, I still recommend pressing the finished custard through a fine mesh strainer or sieve, if you have one. I was taught to do this in culinary school to REALLY ensure a very smooth custard for your apple tart (same with the custard bases for my blueberry cheesecake ice cream and vanilla bean creme brulee).

Long rectangle apple rose tart on vintage baking pan with powdered sugar sifter.

It’s best to use a mandoline to slice the apples for this apple rose dessert.

To be completely honest, you’ll want a mandoline for this apple rose tart. You *could* use a very sharp knife to very thinly slice the apples for this apple rose dessert, but you need so many apple slices that a mandoline will just be much, much faster.

And whatever you do, do NOT take the guard off the mandoline. It’s not worth the risk. You’ll need all of your fingers to make the roses for this apple tart.

How to make apple roses:

First, you’ll need to microwave the apple slices briefly, until they are flexible but not mushy (DON’T microwave for as long as it takes to make an apple mug cake!).

From there, you’ll want to work at rose-making until you find the best technique for you for this apple tart. I folded each apple slice over onto itself once, and then rolled the doubled-over slice up like a pinwheel.

I then used another doubled-over apple slice to wrap around the first roll. Repeat as many times as feels comfortable, and then press the rose (apple peel side up) into the custard.

The more slices you use, the larger the rose will be. You can also continue wrapping apple slices onto the rose once it is settled into the peanut butter custard.

I liked the look of some roses being larger and some being smaller in this apple rose tart, but if you’d like each rose to be more uniform, go ahead and do that. Just like with my mini Hasselback potatoes, this dish doesn’t have to be perfect to still be stunning.

I think the roses would make this perfect for Valentine’s Day, don’t you agree? Maybe as a sweet ending after having a bunch of Valentine’s Day snacks for dinner, unless you’re already making Valentine’s dessert shooters.

Tart made with peanut butter custard and apple "rose" on vintage baking pan.

A note about placing the roses in the peanut butter custard:

Think and act like Julia Child flipping an egg here. Be confident and couragous!

Do NOT worry about messing up the custard in this apple rose tart a little bit when you press the roses into it. It just comes with the territory – you HAVE to mess up the peanut butter custard a little to get the roses to stand up in it.

Once the whole apple tart is covered in roses, you won’t be able to see the custard anyway, so do. not. worry. about. it.

Finish the apple rose tart with glaze:

If you’re planning to serve the apple tart right away, glazing is optional, but still preferred to give the tart a shiny finished look. If you’re making the apple rose dessert a few hours before serving it, the glaze is necessary to prevent the apples from drying out.

The glaze is a simple mixture of apricot preserves and water, and you’ll use a pastry brush to lightly brush it over the roses. Use leftover apricot preserves to make apricot glazed salmon for dinner, or a use them to fill a batch of shortbread thumbprint cookies!